Botox for Migraine
Over the past few years, there has been increased interest in using Botox for migraine. Some people feel it has been an almost miraculous solution for them. But the trials and research hasn't always been convincing. Is Botox for migraines something you should try?
A little background on Botox
Botox is botulinum toxin, a toxin produced by bacteria. It's actually extremely poisonous, and often is ingested as a result of not handling and cooking meat properly (botulism is often fatal).
But botulinum toxin A (Botox) has become famous for it's other application - getting rid of wrinkles. The treatment was discovered in Canada in 1987 by Jean and Alastair Carruthers, and since then brand names Botox, Neurobloc and Myobloc (botulinum toxin B) have been used (in very small doses) to decrease wrinkles and frown lines.
But the next discovery was that patients with migraine found their attacks to be decreasing when they had Botox treatment. Why was this happening? Was it just a coincidence?
Since then, research has begun to try to understand why it works, and when it works, and how Botox for migraine might best be used.
How does it work?
In your body, a chemical (neurotransmitter) known as acetylcholine sends signals for muscles to contract. Botox as a toxin binds the nerve endings, blocking the release of the chemical. Essentially, your muscles don't get the message to contract, and so they relax. In a proper treatment, the muscles won't contract (causing wrinkles), but will still have enough strength for normal use.
Why it may work to relieve migraine is not certain. Could it just be that relaxing certain muscles slows the migraine chain reaction? It's more likely that it blocks pain signals, or may even block signals that contribute to the migraine.
An article at the Mayo Clinic simply says,"the drug may cause changes in your nervous system that modify your tendency to develop migraines".
Botox injected in the forehead for migraines
Botox for migraine - injections
So just how is Botox for migraines used? Well, one way is through simple injections. The treatment is given in a series of shots. Some patients have found almost immediate relief. But the interesting thing is that the improvement tends to last for several months.
The injections may be expensive. Many patients need to weigh the cost against the amount of improvement they receive and the length of time the injections seem to help for. It's important to discuss the option with your doctor and keep a headache diary.
Neither are all injections created equal. Sometimes injections are simply done in a band-like fashion around the skull. But as our understanding increases about what works, different approaches, more specific approaches are being taken.
For example, Dr Jeffrey E. Janis advocates finding "peripheral trigger points", using them as a roadmap to use Botox for migraine.
Read more here about what Botox headache injections are like.
Botox and surgery
Dr. Janis' believes that this process can go even farther. The newer idea is that the Botox injections can find those trigger points - and then surgery can do the rest.
Instead of using a shotgun approach - simply injecting everyone the same way - some researchers believe that you can use the injections as a test. Which muscles are triggering the migraine attacks? If those specific muscles can be found, surgery can keep the problem from resurfacing in the future.
Dr Janis explains: "It's like a math equation. I will inject the Botox into one trigger point at a time and leave the others alone. The Botox is used as a diagnostic test to determine what trigger point is causing the problem. If patients get a benefit from the Botox, they likely will get a benefit from the surgery. If there's no benefit from the Botox, then there won't be a benefit from the surgery."
This treatment has some very controversial aspects. Of course, most are sceptical that migraine can be relieved by focusing on muscles. Though muscle problems may be a trigger, it's generally accepted that the migraine problem itself lies deep in the brain. Muscle issues may actually be a trigger in only a few migraine sufferers.
Still not ready for prime-time?
Groups like the American Academy of Neurology are not ready to accept Botox for migraine as a major treatment. In the spring of 2008, they suggested that Botox injections were no better than a placebo, based on the current evidence. (Read Botox Works on Muscle Disorders But Not Migraines) They recommended that this treatment not be suggested for people with episodic migraine and chronic tension-type headaches.
But wait - what about all these people that claim Botox has changed their lives, by relieving migraine? Well, the fact of the matter is that the research is still in its infancy. It seems that Botox treatments do work, for some. And for some they work very well.
But when compared against the many other treatments out there, the evidence still needs to be built up. In other words, there are many other things you can try, and probably should try, before you try Botox for migraine.
Some research is starting to suggest that patients with certain kinds of migraine pain may benefit most from Botox. That would explain why the more general studies don't show the same improvements. (Read this study on exploding vs imploding headache, for example, from 2007)
And different studies measure things differently. For example, what if Botox for migraines decreased the frequency of migraine attacks, but not the intensity?
If you are interested in trying Botox, take a look at some of the latest techniques, and discuss them with your doctor. Be sure you have a good idea what else is out there, and what the pros and cons are.
Read more about some of the earlier Botox for migraine studies here.
References and further reading: Innovative treatment for migraines combines Botox and surgery Feb 2007; Mayo Clinic article on Migraine Treatment and Drugs June 2007; Botox Works on Muscle Disorders But Not Migraines May 2008; Poison your migraine? Botox injections for use in migraine prevention December 2003; Botox shots may help ward off migraines July 2008; Drug Profiles: Botox® (botulinum toxin); How Botox Works from Bellaire Neurology; Botulinum Toxin: A Poison That Can Heal FDA Consumer Magazine December 1995; Migraine and Other Headaches by Young and Silberstein 2004; 'My surgery left me migraine free' BBC report July 2008